Unfair and Dishonest Criticism of Christian Activism
Most recently, I saw this type of criticism at the blog Crime & Federalism in a post by blogger Mike titled “Pope to Jesus: Kiss Off!
(The omitted portion in the middle contended that having children is a selfish thing to do.) I think that people who tend to criticize Catholics and other Christians for concentrating on abortion and same sex marriage while supposedly “ignoring” other problems fail to recognize why it appears that the Church is “preoccupied.” There are strong movements to legitimize both practices (and in the case of abortion, an already successful movement). It is natural for the Church to assemble its forces to counterattack. And given that both sides have mobilized in political and legal circles, it is natural that you would hear the most about these issues. I suspect that for most such critics, this type of argument is not made to actually further the fight against poverty, or slavery, or whatever other “ignored” issue is pointed out, but to try to shame the Church into abandoning the battlefield on the high-profile issues so the “progressives” can proceed unopposed (good luck with that). And just who is consumed with these issues, anyway? Stop pushing abortion and gay marriage from the left, and the Christian right will have nothing to push back against. In other words, Christian activism on these issues is largely reactive, not proactive. Why on earth someone like blogger Mike would assume that because the Church actively fights vociferous proponents of legalizing and legitimizing practices that are immoral in the eyes of the Church, it “doesn’t care” about other injustices? Because he doesn’t see it on the news? There are millions of Christians in this country alone that give their time and money to fight poverty, homelessness, addiction, domestic violence, etc., and more overseas that fight violence, slavery, forced prostitution, and other evils. A similar, but more thoughtful and less insulting version of the point was made by CNN’s Roland S. Martin (right). Apparently a professing Christian, he posted a column to his website last year titled “Christians: It’s time to take back the faith”:
Okay, so far, so good.
Putting aside the question of what the hell Jackson and Sharpton would do if they couldn’t cry racism all the time — and questioning Martin’s placement of Rick Warren with more conservative figures — I’m trying to imagine the common ground Martin thinks these folks might come to. Which brings me to the disparate treatment of the Religious Left and Religious Right. But that post is for another day. 2 comments to Unfair and Dishonest Criticism of Christian ActivismYour incentive to comment: |
||
|
Copyright © 2010 The Skepticrats - All Rights Reserved |
||
Nobody ever asks same-sex marriage advocates why they advocate same-sex marriage instead of helping orphans.
[...] been heavily pushed by the left, and the righty evangelicals are pushing back. As I have written before, when the left starts pushing for other evils, they will see pushback from the righty [...]